If you see mortgage rates dropping in 2020, you may consider doing a mortgage refinance. But whether you should do it depends on many factors. It could be logical to refinance your home in these scenarios:

  • You are able to refinance your fixed rate home mortgage into a lower fixed rate program, and do it with zero closing costs.
  • A major charge in market conditions, such as a significant change in rates or a rise in home prices, makes it beneficial to refinance.
  • You are able to use a cash out refinance to pay off high interest debt, make major home improvements, etc.

Refinance or No?

Are you still unsure if you should refinance your house? Many people feel the same way. Even when rates drop significantly, the decision to refinance your home mortgage can be uncertain at best. One of the problems is that the rules of thumb we have learned about when to refinance do not always make sense. (themortgagereports.com)

So, homeowners may refinance when it does not make sense, and do not refinance when they should.

Home Refinance Overview

Refinancing your mortgage means replacing your current mortgage with a new loan. With the refinance, the balance of your current loan is paid using the balance of your new mortgage loan. When the refi is done, the old loan no longer exists. It is replaced with an entirely new mortgage with new terms.

There are many good reasons why homeowners want to do a mortgage refinance. A homeowner may want to exploit changes in the mortgage market, including a sudden drop in rates. A new loan can provide you with a much lower rate and payments, and may get rid of pesky private mortgage insurance or PMI.

In other cases, the homeowner may refinance to pull out cash for a home improvement job, to fulfill some type of legal obligation, such as take your ex-spouse off the loan. There are literally dozens of reasons why you might want to refinance. But the most common ones are to drop the rate and drop the monthly payments.

As you consider a mortgage refinance, define what your primary goal is first. Determine what you are attempting to accomplish. Then, think about all of your possible mortgage refinance opportunities.

For example, if you have an FHA loan, you could refinance it with the FHA Streamline Refinance program. This does not require any income, assets or credit verification. Nor does the home need to be appraised. This is an easy way to refinance if you just want to get a lower rate.

Or, consider doing a refinance from FHA into a conventional mortgage that could allow you to cancel FHA’s expensive mortgage insurance.

The Flaw of the Break Even Method

When you mulling a refinance, many financial experts will have you consider the ‘break even method.’ This determines the number of months it takes to get back the costs of the refi. Then, you decide if you will have your home loan for more or less than those months.

Thus, if your loan payment now is $1500, and your payment after the refinance is $1400, and you have $1000 in closing costs, you can figure out the break even in this way:

  • Refinance cost: $1000
  • Savings per month: $100
  • Break even point: 10 months

If the break even point for the new loan is 10 months, and you want to keep the loan for a year, it could make sense to refinance. But if you have been in your current loan for years, the break even calculation may not add up. The problem is related to the new starting balance on the loan. This is lower than what the beginning balance on your existing loan several years ago.

Your new starting balance is lower than your old one. Because a mortgage payment is the same every month, you will get a reduction in payment from the restart of the loan.

Zero Closing Cost Refinance

Another good time to refinance is when you are refinancing a fixed rate mortgage into lower rate product and have zero closing costs. The lender pays all the closing costs. In exchange, you pay for a slight increase in the mortgage rate. This does not give you the lowest possible rate, but you still can save money on your rate and not pay up front money.

If you think that extending your mortgage a few more years is an uncomfortable prospect, you do have the right to pay as much of your loan each month as you like. You can keep sending the previous mortgage payment on the old loan to the lender, and the new mortgage will be paid off faster.


Deciding if house refinancing is for you can be tricky. But there are ways to determine if a mortgage refinance fits your personal and financial goals.